Hi, my name's Vanessa Black and I live in eThekwini in South Africa. I just want to say that I don't think that carbon trading is a way for us to solve climate problems which is one of the most serious problems we face at the moment. We can't just try to trade out way out of this. We all have to take this a lot more seriously and start thinking about how our economies are structured, how our lives are structured. It's not just about each individual trying to save energy alone. It's about us all working together to live in a completely different way, where we're not relying on goods that are sent all over the world. Where we're not trading all over for things we could be growing in our own gardens or our backyard. It's about the way we plan our settlements. So that we're working and living and communicating with people around us, not completely isolated and then trading with people on the other side of the planet.
Africa
I'm living here in South Africa near the oil refinery with my husband. And for sixteen years I had no problem. But since I came here to Merebank, David my husband fell sick. He was here for a few weeks and he was not well. As soon as he comes home, he gets sick. His legs get swollen up, his head starts spinning, he gets diarrhea. Now things are a little hard because he comes and he goes to Johannesburg. He can't even travel by car, he has to travel by plane. He has to go and come. I told him to go live there and come down in January. And it's hard for me to live like this. He always leaves me and then comes and goes. There's money problems. I'm a pensioner. He's a pensioner too. Money is just enough for our rent. Our rent comes to R800 sometimes R700. That's how I am living. I've also got a skin problem too. I didn't have this problem before. My mother died with no problem. But since I came here I also got this skin problem. My face, my neck. I'm also suffering with this skin problem.
Industry and government should start looking at moving us away from fossil fuels. We should be looking for a new energy sources for the world. We should realise that fossil fuels, all these oils and stuff, is a dying energy. It's not going to last long. We should start now looking for alternative energy. We should look for energy that is renewable and energy which is going to be leading us to the future.
Hi, my name is Siziwe Khanyile from South Africa. My position personally is that I don't believe that carbon trading is a solution for climate change. My opinion is that the World Bank should reduce funding to extractive industries and fossil fuel industries and focus on renewable energies to reduce the greenhouse gas emissions and reduce the impact of climate change.
My name is Roy Nyer. I live in South Africa in South Durban where we are surrounded by large companies that pollute our area. I worked for Mondi for a period of twenty years. Mondi paper company that produces paper and newsprint. My concern is that two of my kids have been affected with sickness through the pollution. And on my investigation I found out that the company that I worked for for twenty years has been a contributing factor to the cause of my children's sickness. One of the reasons I believe that the industries have been built close to our community, predominantly an Indian community, is they've taken advantage of our passivity. We are a race that does not fight very aggressively. Whenever we want to bring our concerns, it's done very passively. This is the reason I believe that most of the industries have come and built their factories close to us because they would not get any violent reactions or violent protest. That's one of the reasons why they have built the company. The other reason is that we are poor. And they realised that as an Indian community that we always believed in family values. That our families would not let us lose our jobs. The companies knew that. Being poor, we would be scared of losing our jobs, so whatever they have done by polluting the area or causing any concern to our community, that we would not fight back. Because we're scared to lose out jobs and if we lose our jobs our families would suffer.
Hello my name is Muna Lakhani and I'm a black South African. I'd just like to share one or two thoughts about why many of us believe that nuclear power is no solution to climate change. Firstly it's a highly toxic environment that we would create for people for hundreds of thousands of years. And while it's true that the power plant doesn't generate much in the way of climate changing gases, the reality is that the life cycle of uranium actually generates an awful amount. Particularly mining, uranium enrichment and of course long-term disposal. It's also very expensive technology as far as energy is concerned. In the last fifty years of nuclear power in the USA shows that the energy generated by nuclear was only 20% of that which it consumed. It's overall a dead loss to the energy system. So we would rather go for our beautiful natural resources here in the warm South and use solar-thermal technologies, tidal waves, and all these human and development-benign technologies rather than the toxic wastes of nuclear development. Here's a clear message to everybody involved about sustainable development, about caring for people and planet, nuclear will never be the answer. Thank you.
My name is Mpumelelo Mhlalisi. I'm from Capetown in South Africa from an organisation called Earthlife Africa and also part of the Environmental Justice Networking Forum – the energy task team. What I feel about the issue of climate change is the fact that until now this issue has mostly been discussed by the elites and the converted. People who know about it. And there has been less or little discussion with the people on the ground that is the grassroots people. People who are directly affected by the consequences of the issue of climate change. This issue of climate change directly affects the poor in terms of access to water, access to food, access to work. Because of climate change people are not able to have food, grow their own food, and harvest their own food at the time they used to get their food from. Because of climate change there's less rain and more winter. But ordinary people don't understand that this is the impact of climate change. You get the situation where the people who are the biggest polluter in this world are the people who have access to resources like energy, food, water, transport and all these basic necessities for human life. But the consequences of the whole issue of climate change affects directly the poorest of the poor. Those are the imbalances and the dynamics that we encounter because of the issue of climate change.
I'm Prishani, I'm from South Africa. I work in the Anti-Privatisation Forum in Johannesburg basically struggling for free basic services. I think all of us in our different struggles are fighting against a common enemy – capitalism. I think for too long now we've been too separate in our struggles. We need to start seeing our common enemy and start coming together to fight in our different spaces and the different issues that face us directly.
I live in South Africa, near the oil refinery. This place is polluted with all kinds of rubbish. And my parents and most of the people living in this area died of cancer, asthma and wheezing. What about the little children? We are suffering on this Earth. We are not living a happy life. We are living in a caged up area whereas we're supposed to be living free. We are humans, we are not animals. My brother just died of tumours last year. He just moved here and then he got the tumour and he just died. And the doctors could not find the fault. Only after he died did they find the fault that he had a tumour. We want to live a free life and a fair life. We just want to live a normal life. And we want to give our future generations a pure life.
We don't have a say in how they exploit the planet, we don't have say in how it's done. And if we did I think things would happen in a very different way. But there is this attitude that basically we've got to find a way to make these corporate entities nice. Some of these people that are running these companies are probably very nice people. But it's not because they are nasty that they do these horrific things to the environment, it's because it is highly profitable. And they get subsidised by you and I to actually make that profit. It's called development. That's what the name of the game is. I think we have to be really hard to say look let's look at why this is happening and it's happening because it is a profitable enterprise for people to exploit natural resources. I think a good example of the kind of contradictions people get into is this whole debate about carbon trading. It's absurd. Imagine if you said well okay this year New York only had X number of murders and in Nairobi they had Y number of murders. So Nairobi has under-killed this year so it can sell off how many people can be killed somewhere else. I mean it's absurd. It's not a system we can accept and I think some really hard talking needs to be done about this.